9454 Wilshire Blvd., Penthouse, Beverly Hills, CA 90212 Real estate & construction law across Los Angeles County (310) 276-8800
  1. Home
  2. Practice areas
  3. Easement & Boundary Dispute Attorney in Los Angeles

Easement & Boundary Dispute Attorney in Los Angeles

Driveways, shared walls, hillside retaining walls, a fence six feet over the line. Neighbor disputes in Los Angeles are about inches and decades, and they are won with recorded documents, surveys and the right legal theory.

Quick answer

Harvey Stern handles easement and boundary litigation for property owners in Beverly Hills, Los Angeles and the West Side: blocked or overburdened easements, prescriptive easement claims, encroaching structures, fence and retaining wall cost fights under the Good Neighbor Fence Act, and the quiet title and injunction actions that resolve them. As a licensed general contractor and broker, he can read the survey, the grading plan and the title report himself.

How easement disputes start

An easement is a right to use someone else's land for a specific purpose. In Los Angeles the common ones are driveway and access easements on flag lots and hillside parcels, utility easements, drainage easements, and shared-wall or party-wall agreements in older neighborhoods of Beverly Hills and West Hollywood. Most are recorded. Some were never written down and exist only because people have used them for decades.

The dispute usually begins with a change: a new owner buys the servient parcel and parks across the driveway, a gate goes up, a remodel widens a road or moves a drain, or a neighbor decides the thirty-year-old path across the corner of his lot was a courtesy, not a right. Each of those has an answer in California law.

The legal tools

  • Express easements are interpreted from the recorded grant (Civil Code sections 801 to 813). The fights are over scope: can an access easement for "ingress and egress" carry construction trucks for a year, and can the owner of the burdened lot put a gate on it? The answer depends on the words of the grant and the historic use.
  • Prescriptive easements arise after five years of open, notorious, continuous and hostile use (Code of Civil Procedure sections 321 and 325). Unlike adverse possession, you do not need to have paid the taxes. Proof is photographs, aerials, utility records and witnesses who remember when the path was there.
  • Easements by necessity and implication arise when a parcel was split and one piece was left landlocked or dependent on the other. Common with hillside subdivisions in the Santa Monica Mountains and older lot splits in the Valley.
  • Encroachments. When a structure crosses the line, the court weighs the cost of removal against the harm (the balancing test from Christensen v. Tucker), and can order removal, order a payment in lieu, or grant an equitable easement. Which result you get depends on how the case is framed from the beginning.
  • Fences and retaining walls. Under Civil Code section 841, the Good Neighbor Fence Act, adjoining owners are presumed equally responsible for a shared fence, and an owner who wants a contribution must give thirty days' written notice first. Hillside retaining walls add grading permits, lateral support rights and, often, a construction defect claim against whoever built the wall.
Before you build, before you cut a lock, before you send the angry letter: get the survey and the chain of title. Harvey will tell you what you actually own.

What the firm does

The first step is paper: the title report, the recorded easements going back to the original subdivision map, a current survey, and any photographs or aerials that show use over time. With that in hand, most disputes get a letter that states the legal position clearly and offers a practical resolution, such as a recorded easement agreement with maintenance terms. When a letter does not work, the firm files for quiet title and declaratory relief, and seeks a preliminary injunction when access is being blocked or construction is about to make the problem permanent. Damages, including the cost of restoration and lost use, are claimed where the facts support them.

Harvey has handled these cases for property owners, hillside developers and homeowners associations, and has also been the contractor building the wall and the broker explaining the easement to a buyer. He knows what a grading plan shows about lateral support and what a title report leaves out.

Frequently asked questions

My neighbor put a gate across the easement to my property. Can he do that?

Sometimes. The owner of the burdened property can use the land in any way that does not unreasonably interfere with the easement. Courts have allowed unlocked gates and even locked gates with keys provided, depending on the easement's purpose and history. Whether a particular gate crosses the line depends on the language of the recorded grant and how the easement has been used. A short review of the documents usually answers the question, and a letter usually resolves it.

How long does it take to establish a prescriptive easement in California?

Five years of use that is open, notorious, continuous and hostile to the owner's rights. Occasional or permissive use does not count, and the five years can include prior owners' use if the property changed hands. Proving it is a matter of evidence: dated photos, aerial imagery, neighbors' testimony and sometimes utility or maintenance records.

Who pays for a fence between two properties?

Civil Code section 841 presumes that adjoining owners share equally in the reasonable cost of building and maintaining a shared boundary fence. An owner who wants a contribution must give the neighbor at least thirty days' written notice describing the problem, the proposed solution, the estimated cost and the proposed split. A court can adjust the split if equal sharing would be unfair. Walls, retaining walls and fences well over the line are a different and more involved question.

Can I get an injunction to stop my neighbor's construction?

If the construction encroaches on your property or interferes with a recorded easement, the court can issue a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction while the case is pending. Judges in Los Angeles weigh the harm to each side, so the application needs a survey, the recorded documents and a clear showing that money alone will not fix the problem. The firm has obtained injunctions in boundary cases and also defended against them.

Free consultation

Your case starts with a call

Free consultation with an attorney who has also been the contractor and the broker. In person in Beverly Hills, by phone, or on Zoom.