9454 Wilshire Blvd., Penthouse, Beverly Hills, CA 90212 Real estate & construction law across Los Angeles County (310) 276-8800
  1. Home
  2. Practice areas
  3. HOA Dispute Attorney for Los Angeles Homeowners

HOA Dispute Attorney for Los Angeles Homeowners

Condominium and planned-development owners on the West Side live under CC&Rs enforced by volunteer boards and management companies. When the board gets it wrong, the Davis-Stirling Act gives you tools, and strict rules about using them.

Quick answer

Harvey Stern represents individual owners in disputes with their homeowners associations across Los Angeles County, and advises associations on enforcement and construction matters. Typical cases: a denied remodel, fines for a violation that did not happen, a water leak the HOA refuses to repair, special assessments for construction defects, election and records disputes, and CC&R enforcement against a neighbor the board will not act on. Many are resolved through the Act's mandatory pre-litigation process without a lawsuit.

The rules of the game

Every common-interest development in California, from a Century City high-rise to a six-unit building in West Hollywood, is governed by the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, Civil Code section 4000 and following. The Act controls how boards meet, how assessments are levied, how fines are imposed, how elections are run, what records members can inspect, and how disputes have to be handled before anyone sues.

Two provisions decide most cases. Section 5930 requires that before an owner or an association files a lawsuit for declaratory or injunctive relief to enforce the governing documents, the parties must try alternative dispute resolution. Skip it and the case is dismissed. Section 5975 awards attorney's fees to the prevailing party in an action to enforce the governing documents, in both directions. That fee-shifting is why HOA cases are worth taking seriously from the first letter.

Disputes the firm handles

  • Architectural review. A kitchen remodel, hardwood over carpet, a rooftop deck, an EV charger (which associations cannot unreasonably refuse under section 4745). Section 4765 requires a fair, reasonable and expeditious process and a written decision explaining a denial. As a licensed contractor, Harvey can speak to the construction issues the board is worried about, and often the project gets approved on a revised plan.
  • Water intrusion and repair responsibility. Who fixes the pipe inside the wall, the balcony waterproofing, the window? The answer is in the CC&Rs' definition of common area, exclusive-use common area and separate interest (section 4775), and in the inspection records. These cases often become construction defect cases against the original builder or a repair contractor.
  • Fines, suspensions and towing. Fines require notice and a hearing (section 5855) and a published fine schedule. A fine imposed without them is unenforceable.
  • Assessments and collections. Special assessments, emergency assessments, and liens and foreclosure under sections 5650 to 5740, where the Act's notice and payment-plan requirements are strict and frequently ignored.
  • Elections, meetings and records. Recall campaigns, contested elections (section 5100 and following), closed-door decisions that should have been in open session, and requests for financial records and minutes under section 5200.
  • CC&R enforcement against a neighbor. Short-term rentals, noise, unapproved construction, and the association that will not act. Owners can enforce the CC&Rs directly after exhausting the Act's requirements.
An HOA case is a document case. Harvey starts with the CC&Rs, the rules, the minutes and the correspondence, and tells you where you stand before anyone spends money.

How a case usually goes

Most HOA disputes resolve in the pre-litigation stage if the owner's position is laid out clearly and the board is reminded of the fee exposure. The firm prepares a Request for Resolution under section 5935 that reads like a brief, participates in the ADR session, and documents the association's refusals. If the case proceeds, it is filed in Los Angeles Superior Court, and the firm seeks fees under section 5975 at the end.

The firm also represents associations and boards, particularly on construction defect claims against developers, repair contracts, and enforcement against owners whose unpermitted work affects the building. Harvey's contractor's license means he can evaluate a balcony inspection report under the balcony law (section 5551) or a repair bid without waiting for an expert.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to go through mediation before suing my HOA?

If you are seeking declaratory or injunctive relief to enforce the CC&Rs, bylaws or rules, yes. Civil Code section 5930 requires an offer of alternative dispute resolution first, and a case filed without it will be dismissed. The offer is made through a Request for Resolution under section 5935, and the other side has thirty days to accept. Claims for money damages only, and certain small claims matters, are exempt.

The HOA denied my remodel. What can I do?

Ask for the written decision, which section 4765 requires to explain the reasons and the appeal process. Many denials fail because the association has no written architectural standards, applied them inconsistently, or missed its own deadline. Harvey reviews the governing documents and the plans, often proposes a revised design that addresses the board's stated concern, and if the board still refuses without a reasonable basis, pursues the dispute through ADR and, if necessary, court.

Can the HOA fine me without a hearing?

No. Civil Code section 5855 requires written notice at least ten days before a board meeting at which a fine or suspension will be considered, and the owner must be given the chance to be heard. The association must also have adopted and distributed a schedule of fines. Fines imposed without those steps can be challenged and reversed.

Who is responsible for a leak from the unit above me?

Start with the CC&Rs. Typically the association maintains common area, the owner maintains the separate interest, and exclusive-use common area such as balconies and patios is split. A pipe serving only one unit is often the owner's; a pipe inside a common wall serving several units is often the association's. Negligence by the upstairs owner, or a defect in the building's original construction, changes the analysis and may bring in an insurance carrier or the builder.

Free consultation

Your case starts with a call

Free consultation with an attorney who has also been the contractor and the broker. In person in Beverly Hills, by phone, or on Zoom.