A change order is a written amendment to a construction contract that changes the scope of work, the price, the schedule, or all three. It should describe the change, state the added or deducted cost and any schedule impact, and be signed by the owner and the contractor before the changed work is performed. Budgets fail when changes are made verbally and priced later, when allowances are set unrealistically low, and when unforeseen conditions are discovered without a procedure for handling them.
Where changes come from
Three sources, in order of frequency. The owner changes the plans: a bigger island, a different tile, a wall that should come out after all. Unforeseen conditions: the old plumbing behind the wall, the termite damage under the floor, the soil that will not hold the footing. And the plans were wrong or incomplete, which is a design problem that becomes a construction change. Every one of these is legitimate. The problem is not that changes happen; it is that they are not priced and agreed in writing before the work is done.
What a proper change order contains
- A number and a date, so the sequence is clear.
- A description of the change specific enough that a stranger could see it on the job site.
- The price: added cost, deducted cost or no cost, with a breakdown for labor, materials, subcontractors, overhead and profit.
- The schedule impact in days.
- The new contract sum and the new completion date after the change.
- Signatures of the owner and the contractor, before the work.
A text message that says "go ahead" is not a change order, although it may be evidence of one.
Why unsigned extras cause lawsuits
At the end of the project the contractor presents a final invoice with $90,000 of extras the owner never signed for. The owner says the contract required written change orders and refuses to pay. The contractor says the owner stood there and watched the work and asked for half of it. California courts resolve this on the facts: a written change order requirement can be waived by the parties' course of conduct, and an owner who directed or knowingly accepted the work may owe its reasonable value; a contractor who did extra work on its own initiative without approval may not be paid for it. The daily logs, the emails and the photographs decide the case, which is expensive to litigate and avoidable with a signature.
Allowances: the quiet budget killer
An allowance is a placeholder in the contract for an item not yet selected: $8,000 for appliances, $15 per square foot for tile. When the owner selects $35,000 of appliances, the difference is a change order whether anyone calls it that or not. Allowances that are set low to make the bid look attractive are the single most common reason a project runs over. Set them realistically, and treat every selection over the allowance as a change order to be signed.
Controlling the process
For owners: make decisions before the work reaches that stage, insist on a signed change order before any changed work, and keep a running log of the contract sum. For contractors: stop and price the change before doing it, even if it costs a day, and never let a project end with unsigned extras. For both: a contract with a clear change order procedure, which the firm drafts and reviews on the construction contracts page.
Related questions
Can a contractor refuse to do extra work without a signed change order?
Yes, and a careful contractor will. The contract governs the scope; work outside it is not required until the parties agree on the change in writing. An owner who wants the change should expect to sign for it.
What is a reasonable markup on a change order?
Many residential contracts set overhead and profit on changes at 10 to 20 percent combined, on top of the direct cost of labor, materials and subcontractors. Whatever the number, it should be in the contract so it is not negotiated under pressure on the job site.
The contractor found unforeseen conditions. Do I have to pay for the extra work?
Usually yes, if the condition was genuinely unforeseeable and the contract has a differing site conditions or unforeseen conditions clause, which most do. The contractor still has to stop, document the condition and price the change before proceeding. Paying for an unforeseen condition does not mean paying whatever is asked.
This article is general information about California law, not legal advice for your situation. Facts matter; deadlines run. For advice on your own matter, request a free consultation.

